The Cleveland Browns’ $230 million bust

Reading time: 4 Min

The Cleveland Browns are facing a situation that is even for NFL-conditions is unprecedented. The former hopeful Deshaun Watson has gone from a supposed franchise savior to a financial and sporting bust that threatens to crush the future of the organization.

From hope to disillusionment: The decline of Deshaun Watson.

When the Browns signed Watson in 2022, the expectations were clear: He was supposed to lead the team to new heights. But the reality is different. In his third season under head coach Kevin Stefanski, Watson not only shows no improvement, but even seems to be regressing. The recent loss to the Dallas Cowboys ruthlessly revealed his current weaknesses.

With a pass percentage of just 24 successful throws out of 45 attempts and a meager 3.8 yards per attempt, Watson delivered a performance unworthy of a starting quarterback in the NFL. Two interceptions and six sacks rounded off the picture of a disastrous performance. It is a performance that in any other situation would inevitably lead to a demotion to the bench or even a firing.

The most expensive mistake in NFL history?

But the Browns find themselves in a predicament that is unparalleled. Watson’s contract, which guarantees him two more fully guaranteed annual salaries of $46 million each, makes any kind of sporting consequence almost impossible. An early separation before the 2025 season would burden the Browns with a dead money hit of an incredible $173 million – a sum that is astronomical even by NFL standards.

This contractual situation forces the Browns to continue using Watson next year, despite a $72.9 million cap hit. It’s a financial burden that will impact team planning for years to come and will minimally limit the Browns’ flexibility on the transfer market.

Trapped in your own strategy.

The combination of a questionable trade and an even more questionable contract has left the Browns in a dead end with no easy way out. What was intended to be a bold move to bring a struggling franchise back to the top has turned out to be perhaps the most costly mistake in NFL history.

The Browns now have no choice but to wait it out and hope that Watson will somehow return to his previous form. But with each disappointing performance, that hope is fading. The organization must now watch as its chance to build a sustainable playoff contender has been destroyed by a single, albeit monumental, mistake.

The current situation is particularly bitter for Browns fans who have waited decades for breakthrough success. The signing of Watson was supposed to be the long-awaited turning point. Instead, they are now faced with the prospect of having to endure more years of mediocrity, shackled by a contract that leaves no room for change.

Our recommendations for you

Terms used in this article

Get the daily NFL newsletter!