Lily Collins chooses her favorite Phil Collins song, but can’t name a Genesis song

Lily Collins has previously mentioned that she was not particularly close to her father during her childhood. She also does not have many early memories of his band Genesis, as they split up when she was 11. Many of her father’s most famous songs were released before she was even born. But during the Emily in Paris Star’s latest guest visit to See what’s happening liveAndy Cohen just had to ask: “What is Lily Collins’ favorite Phil Collins song?”

“Probably ‘In The Air Tonight’… I don’t know, there are too many,” Lily replied, to which Cohen asked, “Do you have a favorite Genesis song?”

“The funny thing is, I have memories of songs as a child that I don’t know if they’re real,” Lily explained. “Because they were in my head, maybe even when I was in the womb. But then when I went to the first Genesis concert that I actually remember as an adult, there were songs that made me think, ‘That’s a real song?’ I thought it was just a melody in my head. It was really weird.”

Sometimes it’s smart to play it safe with your interview answers. Watch the clip below.